Economic theory provides elegant statements of the conditions under which tax competition may be a force for good or a force for bad. An analysis of taxation across swiss municipalities lends support to that argument. Some business leaders benefited greatly from the governments restriction of competition and other wartime controls. This is not plausible, but it is a prediction for a scenario with a smallness of.
From frank herbert and william gibson to neal stephenson and orson scott card, the best science fiction books of all time. In this context, tax competition plays an important role in limiting budgetmaximizing behavior of government officials. The benefits of tax competition institute of economic. In their 1980 book the power to tax, geoffrey brennan and james m. We study the impact of tax competition on equilibrium taxes and welfare. The analysis of these new data in a range of projects has generated new and robust evidence on fiscal interdependencies among local governments and on behavioral responses of households facing local differences this. Slaying leviathan issues a devastating indictment of the absurdity that has masqueraded as tax policy for the last century. Thomas hobbes leviathan, from 1651, is one of the first and most influential arguments towards social contract. Tax competition news newspapers books scholar jstor may 2010 learn how. Tax harmonisation has been controversial since the establishment of the european economic community, and corporation tax proposals are currently on the table in the eu. A test of the leviathan hypothesis mercatus center. This increasingly intense competition for power, in turn, selects.
The intensity of tax competition is modelled via variation of a parameter. Opinion how to end international tax competition the. This article critically examines thehypothesis of brennan and buchanan that competition amonggovernments in the provision of publicgoods can serve as a substitute forconstitutional constraints on governments. The paper analyses the impact of tax competition on innovation in the public sector. The importance of taxation regimes as an essential factor in driving economic growth, investment inflows and national development has increasingly been recognised. Opponents of international tax harmonisation argue that tax competition can rein in the taxraising powers of biggovernment leviathans and. Attitudes towards downward pressure on tax rates from international tax competition depend on attitudes towards government. Capital tax competition and dynamic optimal taxation, carleton economic papers 8, carleton university, department of economics. In a dazzling work of graphic fiction, a surreal journey through a wonderland eerily like real life, the book of leviathan chronicles an infants investigations into lifes great mysteries. It is often thought that tax competition causes tax rates to be set too low. This creates incentives which lead governments to undercut one another on tax rates in order to attract investment from abroad while preventing an exodus of capital.
Tax competition occurs when different countries seek to attract investment and multinational companies, by offering lower tax rates. National tax journal, september 20, 66 3, 745774 what do we know about corporate tax competition. Tax competition and leviathan jeremy edwards a, michael keen b,c a faculty of economics and polifics. Here youll find current best sellers in books, new releases in books, deals in books, kindle ebooks, audible audiobooks, and so much more. This paper discusses many of the contributions to this literature, ranging from early demonstrations of wasteful tax competition to more recent. In his magisterial crisis and leviathan, robert higgs shows that the growth of government in the twentieth century can largely be explained by patterns of crisis and response. Although tax competition can be beneficial, tax harmonisation could curb tax competition that leads to the underprovision of public goods or to burdenshifting from mobile to immobile tax bases. Tax competition and leviathan, cesifo working paper series 57, cesifo group munich. University of cambridge, sidgwick avenue cambridge, cb3 idd, uk b department of economics, university of essex, wivenhoe park, colchester co4 3sq, uk institute for fiscal studies, london, uk. This form of competition is commonly referred to as the horizontal tax competition, because it implies competition between governments at the same level. Tax competition causes inequality within and across borders does the existence of tax competition invalidate the optimists argument that it does not constrain national policy choices. Both tax and rent seeking competitions are conceived of as being wasteful and selfdefeating. If, however there is not sufficient coordination,tax competition leads to low capital income taxes and the tax burden falls on the internationally immobile factors. In nations that are members of the organization for economic cooperation and development.
Over the last six years, researchers collaborating through the snf sinergia project have collected data on fiscal federalism in switzerland over more than half a century. Pdf in this chapter, we argue that tax competition is resilient because. As long as tax revenue remains more or less stable, one may think. International tax competition has come to the forefront of global economic policy debate at the outset of the 21st century. The results of global tax competition are staggering.
Tax competition, imperfect capital mobility and the gain from nonpreferential agreements, departmental working papers 0804, southern methodist university, department of economics. Buchanan propose the so called leviathan hypothesis. Tax competition can take many forms, according to the goals. Written in the midst of the english civil war, it concerns the structure of government and society and argues for strong central governance and the rule of an absolute sovereign as the way to avoid civil war and chaos. This study investigates how the sustainability of partial tax coordination among a subset of countries i. International aspects of corporate income taxes and. Implications for tax competition, cofe discussion papers 0033, university of konstanz, center of finance and econometrics cofe. The first step is to look at the baseline model of tax competition on which most of the literature implicitly. A central message of the tax competition literature is that independent governments engage in wasteful competition for scarce capital through reductions in tax rates and public expenditure levels.
Often, this means a governmental strategy of attracting foreign direct investment, foreign indirect investment financial investment, and high value human resources by minimizing the overall. The repec blog the repec plagiarism page tax competition and leviathan. Public economics we develop a tax competition framework in which some jurisdictions, called tax havens, are parasitic on the revenues of other countries. We characterize theoretically and empirically the conditions under which tax. Pdf winners and losers of tax competition researchgate. It restricts the growth of public finance and curbs the expansion of a leviathan state. The present paper provides a basis for evaluating fiscal decentralization of expenditure and tax responsibilities, by encompassing the literature on tax competition and rent seeking. The outcome is nevertheless still efficient relative to the available constrained set of tax instruments. For by art is created that great leviathan called a commonwealth, or state in latin, civitas, which is but an artificial man, though of greater stature and strength than the natural, for whose protection and defence it was intended. Tax competition in europe or the taming of leviathan by alain steichen professor at the centre universitaire luxembourg the best test of truth is the power of the thought to get itself accepted in the competition of the market justice oliver wendell holmes, dissenting, abrams et al.
Tax competition, a form of regulatory competition, exists when governments use reductions in fiscal burdens to encourage the inflow of productive resources or to discourage the exodus of those resources. The welfare effects of tax competition reconsidered. In both cases, we focus on the efficiency effects of tax competition, and whether these effects can be distinguished empirically. Taxation of investment and finance in an international setting. The rise of tax competition and the battle to defend it chris edwards and daniel j. This implies that, without intracantonal tax competition, leviathan municipalities average tax rate is more than seven times e 2. Introduction in their 1980 book the power to tax, geoffrey brennan and james m. In either case new government programs, agencies, and policies are established, purportedly as. These crises can be real world wars i and ii, the great depression, stagflation or imagined inequality, the various isms.
Tax competition refers to strategic tax setting in a noncooperative game between jurisdictions whether countries or states or provinces within a federation with each setting some parameters of its tax system in relation to the taxes set by others. No 54, thuenenseries of applied economic theory from university of rostock, institute of economics abstract. Edwards and keen 1996, for example, show that the net welfare effect of tax com. The federal income tax and the federal reserve system were two key legacies of the progressive era, but even more important was the profound shift that occurred in the thinking of the nations intellectuals and business leaders. Wasteful behaviour is restricted by the voter, who reduces political support if her income is reduced. It is shown that the effects of increased mobility of the tax base on innovation and growth are ambiguous. Usually tax competition refers to corporation tax, but can also include competition on income tax on labour. Tax competition, capital mobility, and innovation in the public sector. Theories of tax competition national tax association. The book demonstrates the enormous benefits that come from tax competition and outlines the current threats to tax competition from the eu and the oecd. The oecd also complained in various reports that lowtax policies unfairly erode the tax bases of other countries. Tax competition and leviathon, ifs working papers w9407, institute for fiscal studies.
Econpapers faq archive maintainers faq cookies at econpapers. Of the consequence or trayne of imaginations chapter 4. The leviathan hypothesis posits that horizontal competition occurs among. Tax competition occurs when governments set their tax rates noncooperatively. And as power expands in a ratchetingupward way, power becomes evermore valuable and intoxicating to possess meaning that competition to grab power becomes evermore intense. Since leviathantype governments withfree choice of tax instruments will be ableto escape competitive pressure by shiftingtaxes to immobile factors, one could thinkof a rule of. Tax competition, capital mobility, and innovation in the. The rise of tax competition and the battle to defend it. The book begins with a primer on international taxation and then shows why the arguments used by government to justify the prevention of tax competition are fallacious.
Winning the tax wars, an invaluable book, shows how the globalization of trade, the digitization of the economy, tax competition between sovereign states, the erosion of the tax base, and the transfer of profits have all revealed the weaknesses of a traditional tax system that has reached its limits, and how numerous states and groups of. The results of the tax competition literature are mixed to such a degree that it is difficult to draw unambiguous conclusions. Emerging lessons from half a century of fiscal federalism. International tax competition commonwealth bookshop. Are moderate leviathans harmful to tax coordination. Some authors welcome tax competition forcing politicians to lower tax rates and to curb the leviathan state. Tax competition with parasitic tax havens joel slemrod, john d. Opponents of international tax harmonisation argue that tax competition can rein in the taxraising powers of biggovernment leviathans and thereby act as a force for good. The paper addresses this question by means of a simple model of economic growth in which a wasteful leviathan state sets taxes and provides a productive input.
1219 226 919 566 1166 39 359 898 854 1302 1151 25 842 125 177 316 228 1114 270 1230 56 1175 1079 1276 853 1143 551 1139 889 459 981 693 502